This card here is based off a classic pixel-art game, and it's probably the first time in history where that pixel art has been reimagined as 3D fantasy art, so the card plays to people's nostalgia and their imaginations, Nomura said
That is not a rumor
At three mana I really feel the floor on this card is decent but if built around can be much better if you try and maximize the value from both outcomes of the choices here
I do think a lot of effects in this deck might come off as scary to new players, so whoever grabs Chaos Incarnate might get early experience with being hated off the table
The main arguments for unbanning seem to be that there are other powerful ramp options available in the format and that Primeval Titan can be easily shut down with removal
Since the dawn of Magic: The Gathering in 1993, Black Lotus has held an almost mythical status, defining power, strategy, and collectibility in a way no other card has